Secret items: letting players keep things from each other
When a character’s secrets make the story better, how to keep them fair to the rest of the table, and what the game master should see.
Secrets make stories
A stolen letter, a cursed ring nobody wants to admit to, a gift from a rival: what a character hides from the party drives some of the best scenes, on the day the truth comes out.
Keeping it fair
Secrets work when the table agrees they are allowed, ideally at session zero. A few rules keep them from turning players against each other:
- The game master always knows.
- A secret makes the story more interesting; it does not let one character win at the others’ expense.
- When a secret comes out, it comes out in the story, not in an argument about the rules.
The game master’s own secrets
Game masters need hiding places too: what the merchant keeps in the back room, the rival’s treasure the party has not found yet. Keep those apart from anything the players can read.
Revealing things on purpose
The moment something hidden comes to light should be a choice: the player shows the ring, the party finds the hoard. Plan for it as you would plan a scene.
Secrets in Hoardwyn
In Hoardwyn, what a character carries is private to its player and the game master. A player can let the party see their belongings and still hide single things, which stay marked “Hidden from the party” on their own screen.
The game master sees everything, and keeps NPC inventories that players are never told exist, for the shopkeeper’s back room or a rival’s hoard. To hand something over, the game master moves it to a character.