Haggling at the table, without slowing it down
A quick way to bargain over prices that keeps shopping fun, and when not to haggle at all.
Why haggle at all
Haggling turns a purchase into a scene: the shopkeeper has a name and a mood, and the party’s talker gets to shine. Done badly, it is ten minutes of arguing over two coins.
A one-roll method
Keep it to a single exchange:
- The shop names its price; the player says what they offer, and why.
- One roll, with whatever your game uses for persuasion.
- A good result meets the player’s offer, a middling one splits the difference, and a bad one holds the price, or raises it if the player was rude.
Know the range beforehand
Decide how far a shopkeeper will go before the scene, a tenth off or a quarter, so you are not inventing numbers under pressure. A shopkeeper who never moves on price is a character, not a failure.
When not to haggle
Skip it for everyday things like rations and rope, and when the party is in a hurry. Save it for the purchases that matter, where the scene is worth the time.
Haggling when selling
Selling loot works the same way in reverse: the shop names what it pays, and the player argues for more. Keep shops paying less than they charge, or haggling turns loot into easy money.
Shop prices in Hoardwyn
In Hoardwyn, a player chooses “Haggle…” at the shop’s counter and offers what they would pay. The offer waits for the game master, who accepts it, agrees on less, or turns it down; accepted, it is bought at that price at once. At a money changer, “Ask for more…” works the same way.
A character who haggled well can keep a standing discount at a shop: a tenth off, or a markup for one the shopkeeper dislikes. The counter shows it, works it into every total, and the record notes it beside the payment.