How to split treasure fairly
Coins, items and a party fund: ways tables share out a hoard without arguments, and how to keep the result straight.
Agree on the rule before the hoard
Most arguments about loot are not about the loot. They come from a rule nobody said out loud: one player assumed an even split, another that whoever found it keeps it. Settle it once, before the first big haul, ideally in your first session, and the table can get back to the game.
There is no single right rule. What matters is that everybody knows it, and that the result is written down where everybody can see it.
Coins: even shares, and what is left over
Even shares are the simplest rule and the hardest to argue with: count the coins, divide by the number of characters who were there, and hand out the shares.
Count in the smallest coin your game has before dividing. 17 gold among four characters is awkward; 1,700 silver is 425 each. Whatever still does not divide goes into the party fund rather than to whoever asks first.
Decide whether a character whose player missed the session gets a share. Many tables say yes for anyone in the party, so missing a game night is not punished.
Items: need first, then taking turns
Items do not divide. A common approach goes in three rounds:
- Need: whoever can actually use something gets it first. The heavy armor goes to the character who fights in heavy armor.
- Turns: everything nobody needs is picked in turn. Rotate who picks first from one hoard to the next, so the same player is not always last.
- Selling: what is left is sold, and the money is shared like coins.
Some tables count an item’s value against its holder’s share of the coins instead, so taking the valuable sword means taking less gold. It is fairer on paper and slower at the table, and works best when items have clear prices.
Keep a party fund
Set aside a slice of every haul, a tenth or one extra share, for what the whole party needs: healing, a boat, a bribe, rooms at the inn. Nobody pays for the group out of their own pocket, and nobody has to chase anybody for their part.
Write down where everything went
Three sessions later, “who has the health potions?” is a real question. A list of who got what, and when, settles it in seconds. Keep it where every player can read it, not in one person’s notebook.
Splitting treasure in Hoardwyn
In Hoardwyn, every character has its own money and belongings, and a party fund is a shared purse that several characters pay into and take from. The game master puts the hoard into the campaign; from there, money is sent to each character, and items are moved or handed over.
Every movement shows on a statement or an item’s history, with who did it and when, and nothing in them is quietly changed afterward. Amounts are kept as exact whole numbers of the smallest unit, so nothing is ever rounded away.